Animal care for therapy, who is the better for it?

Many people who are psychologically confused and have been seeing psychiatrists or social workers for a while, are advised to become active in animal care, or themselves indicate that they would enjoy this.
The object is that caring for animals will gradually bring structure back into the lives of these people.
Step by step they will learn to bear responsibility again.
This may be the case, but in practice it costs more than it yields.
To give you an idea of what goes on in this voluntary, extra assistance, we present a number of real life cases.
Of course, names have been changed.
A solution to this situation would be if these voluntary animal caregivers were to receive a reasonable compensation for this "therapy" of for example 30 Euro per hour.
This is a relatively high amount, but at least all three parties will gain something, because extra staff can be employed, either to give attention to people or to care for the animals.
Caring for animals is usually the work of volunteers.
When these volunteers also have to support psychologically confused people, than three parties suffer.
  1. The psychological patient who cannot concentrate and needs a lot of attention, is supported by a non-professional.
  2. The volunteers who in their own time have to look out for the interests of animals as well as of their confused fellow man.
  3. The animals that should be cared for by people who are psychologically strong, and independent enough to care for them so that they can return to their own lives in the wild as soon as possible. Psychologically disturbed people are not well equipped for this.
Real life cases. John is 40 years old and a schizophrenic. Silent. Robot-like.
John hears voices. John wants to drive animals to other shelters. But someone has to go with him, because on the way John always receives commands to drive straight on when he approaches a turnoff. But going with him doesn't help either, the voices in his head are stronger than my voice. John is now driving straight on so often that it takes us the entire day to get animals to the shelter.
The animals have to stay in the car way too long, they are ill. John also wants to pick up animals from caller's homes. He then takes them to me for first aid. He absently stares at me when I try to explain that small animals go in small cages and large animals go in large cages.
That the cages or boxes need to be lined with newspapers or hay and that the animals should be firmly fixed to prevent further injury. John nods and nods but repeatedly arrives at our door with dead animals, or without any animals at all. John still puts small animals in large cages with widely spaced bars and without newspapers. The small animals have literally slipped or been slung across the slippery cage floors and out between the bars. Dead or gone. Real life cases.
Nadine is a fashion addict. Made a mess of her life and ended up in a psychiatric clinic. Once outside, she wants to work with animals. On high heels and in a short skirt she turns up for her shift in animal care. Nadine first smokes a cigarette, and a second and a third. Then Nadine wants to call her therapist and then her partner because she thinks he has cheated on her.
She thinks she may be pregnant, she says, and cries. Then she opens her patent leather bag and out come various perfume bottles. The four otherwise well-groomed animal keepers are constantly and literally followed around and sprayed with perfume, endlessly. Nadine is hungry and disappears to the kitchen. She ends with a final cigarette. Talks about her problems and smokes. The animal emergency phone rings and she doesn't notice. On her next shift Nadine turns up right on time, and the entire ritual is repeated.
Urging, kind requests, brief problem discussions, nothing moves Nadine. But Nadine loves to come to us.
Nico is 45 years old. Has permanent brain damage caused by an accident. Does other light work for a children's farm and the water management. Cleaning out cages, changing hay and taking water samples from the river for research. After a call, Nico goes out to pick up wounded animals. Nico poses as a vet or an ecologist, as an animal psychologist, a biologist and an anthropologist. He examines animals at caller's homes and makes diagnoses. During one of these he accidentally squeezes a turtledove to death. He becomes conceited and knows no limits. We have to constantly go with him or rectify his titles with callers. He orders the other volunteers around and claims he is the best.
Jack is 38. He takes medication for psychoses.
He frees an entire flock of geese in his van and transports them. Busted wings, bleeding beaks, the van full of bird-do.
Jack leaves a duck and a parrot in a hot van with the windows rolled up and goes for a cup of coffee somewhere. Forgets about the animals in his car and forgets we are waiting for him. Animals dead.
Jack frees a mother duck and her ducklings in a tiny fountain in a city center without any greenery and in the middle of busy traffic. He doesn't understand our anger and our desperation. He gives us an absent look and asks what else he can do for us?
Marja is a nymphomaniac. Daycare psychiatry. worked in the sex industry. Obsessed with her body. Obviously an animal lover. But she doesn't get round to it. Works out all day to keep her body in shape.
While she takes care of the animals, which she does nicely, she also works out. That doesn't work, the time schedule doesn't allow it. But she cannot help it, something in her mind tells her that she just has to work out. Constantly washes her hands, every minute. Otherwise she gets contaminated, she says. After her shift, we do the chores she hasn't been able to finish. She always arrives on time. She carries on affairs with everyone she meets and wants to sleep with them even on her shift. She has had quite a few.
This causes tensions between the volunteers.
Theo is 32 and chronically unemployed. Psychiatric problems, he says, he can't work.
Goes into disability. The administrative office sends him to us. Wants to do anything for the animals.
After a report about a wounded animal Theo is called to go to the scene. Theo hasn't shaved. The animal is in the middle of the road and has been hit by a car. Theo thinks shaving is more important, because he cannot go outside like this. Theo shaves. A second car has run over the animal before Theo arrives. At the next call Theo wants to finish watching his video first because it is thrilling. A third time Theo places a dangerously wounded small animal openly on the exit to its final destination: the shelter, and leaves it there. A cat finds the animal in its box and kills it.

logoThis page describes one aspect of the influence that man has on the quality of life of an animal. We wish to promote the (in other countries as well) growing of awareness, that freedom is also important for an animal. An animal is not a thing, but a being that has the right to quality of a natural way of life. If you want to do something to help animals, click here for our suggestions.

If you appreciate our site, then please help spreading the articles.

Tip for your language area

The majority of our articles are written in Dutch. We invite you to explore the Dutch sitemap and use the translation function of Google Translate. This way, you can read our message about animal rights, objections to intensive livestock farming, and other topics in your own language.
Here is the URL that translates the sitemap for you.

Animal Freedom Foundation.
Author .

Our main articles in a book, via an overview or on a separate site.

Privacy statement.

Back to the top